Wednesday, March 18, 2009

The Losses from Trade

Advertised in today's New York Times food section on-line, as part of an almost certainly multi-million-dollar product launch, is a heart-breaking example of how resource-rich countries lose tremendous economic development opportunities. Stevia is an herb native to Paraguay that is naturally very sweet. It has been used for hundreds and hundreds of years by Paraguay’s indigenous population in infusions, mate, and simply to chew. A calorie-free sweetener can be extracted from this leaf and has been commonly used in Paraguay for at least a decade if not more. Imagine the potential this has. Replace ubiquitous, cancer-causing, synthesized sweeteners with a naturally occurring, calorie-free sweetener. This is the sort of breakthrough product that could form the base to develop an entire food industry and development strategy in the country that is blessed with such an herb.

Ah, but this is no good, what about high fructose corn syrup? What about saccharine and sucralose and aspartame? No, Stevia was not safe for consumption, according to the FDA. No matter that it has had regulatory approval in Japan for decades with no evidence of worse side effects than synthetic sweeteners. Americans must be kept safe from the ill effects of stevia. That is, until Cargill and Coca-Cola invest in the research, product definition and design, and marketing that can assure that the economic gains from this product be captured in the U.S. Then suddenly stevia is a miracle herb that no readers of the New York Times food section can miss out on and we get Truvia: "the first great-tasting, zero-calorie natural sweetener that's a miracle of nature, not chemistry."

In the meantime China has far surpassed Paraguay as the main grower of Stevia, having had three decades to consolidate its supply links to the Japanese and Korean markets. No Paraguayan Denomination of Controlled Origin; no development of innovative marketing, product definition, logistics, packaging, and branding capacities in Paraguayan companies; no direct relationships between stevia producers and processors in Paraguay and the enormous international food processing industry that will jump all over Truvia to sweeten everything from that Odewalla sludge that gives professional women their healthy edge to the super-gulps at 7-eleven that give other women their healthy bottoms; no mention of Paraguay at all in Truvia's promotional activities.

As Paraguay yet again embraces its role as a primary product exporter, the government’s export promotion agency and ministry of commerce celebrate stevia's regulatory approval in the U.S., laud Coke and Cargill's 'research and development' of Truvia, and congratulate themselves for 'accessing' an enormous market that will soon open up and produce the latest in two centuries of successive export booms that promise to save Paraguay's ever-struggling "pequeños productores" from their perpetual underdevelopment.

Obviously, exploiting the opportunities afforded by Stevia to their fullest potential would require investment, research, development, planning, and coordination that far outstrip the capacities of any of the public or private sector institutions that currently exist in Paraguay. But that is the point. Instead of using this resource as a 'hook' to attract from abroad the resources necessary to develop themselves and upgrade their capacities, these organizations have thrown themselves entirely into the arms of foreign investors and the multinational monopolies supported by US regulatory regimes. What a waste.

12 comments:

Alice said...

this is so heart breaking.

Lucinda said...

ew. so much spam... Anyway, I just wanted to comment that I was actually raised on stevia (from my hippie mom). I'm happy to see that it's catching on, though sad that it's not benefiting Paraguay. At least the people of Paraguay still have it.

Anonymous said...

Варез - качай всё бесплатно.

Anonymous said...

bootleg movie download
[url=http://www.omc-movie.com/?p=6781]The Drawn Together Movie[/url]
movie reviews
[url=http://www.omc-movie.com/?p=6053]How to Train Your Dragon movie[/url]
excellent online movie shop
[url=http://www.omc-movie.com/?p=5788]Ponyo movie[/url]
Orleans
[url=http://www.omc-movie.com/?p=4820]Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs movie[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://god-n-devil-inc.livejournal.com/13959.html]Дизайн внутренних состояний[/url]

Anonymous said...

Design is the thing that you get to be, not what everyone else states it needs to be. You will be your own special individual, and you choose what's important for you. After researching various suggestions, it's your decision to make a decision how you would like to look. Read more for many valuable directing tips.

Usually gown properly for the time of year. You are unable to plan to wear the identical points all through the year due to weather conditions alterations. In the spring and summer conditions, use delicate textile garments that may be lower cut with dazzling hues.[url=http://www.cheapuggukbootssale.co.uk/ugg-men-classic-short-c-3.html]cheap Ugg Men Classic Short[/url] In the tumble and winter, wear natural shades and fabrics, linen, cotton, and leather.

Sun glasses are an excellent accessory to add to your ensemble in the summertime. But, the sort of shades you make can really make or break your look. If you have a circular or huge encounter, greater eyeglasses are the ideal solution.[url=http://www.cheapuggukbootssale.co.uk/ugg-classic-nightfall-c-6.html]cheap Ugg Classic Nightfall[/url] On the other hand, if you have a compact deal with, choose smaller sized shades.

Consider photographs of yourself inside the getting dressed space. To get a legitimate notion of how you look within a new clothing before you purchase it, use your cell phone to click an image of on your own although you're striving it on.[url=http://www.cheapuggukbootssale.co.uk/ugg-classic-short-sparkles-c-9.html]cheap Ugg Classic Short Sparkles[/url] That may be the best way to get a concept of what other people see whenever they look at it.

Attire for you kind. Take the time to recognize your shape, and the way to use clothes to further improve your normal possessions. Females that learn how to work with their body, rather than trying to hide it, are the type individuals discover whenever they enter an area.[url=http://www.cheapuggukbootssale.co.uk/ugg-bailey-button-c-4.html]cheap Ugg Bailey Button[/url] Be pleased with your form, and assist it to enhance your design esteem.

As was reported in the opening of the write-up, it is actually no exciting as a trend disaster. Luckily, improving your design design is not really everything that tough. The tips and advice you've just acquired, if used on your way of life, will assist you to appearance much more stylish than you imagined you might.[url=http://www.cheapuggukbootssale.co.uk/ugg-turn-cuff-gloves-c-17.html]cheap Ugg Turn Cuff Gloves[/url]

Anonymous said...

Meteorite that struck today in Russia from entering the atmosphere have a width of 15 meters - NASA said. According to NASA, a meteor which fell in Russia was higher than that in the 8 October 2009 hit Indonesia. Kredyty

Anonymous said...

http://deiwaltare.tk/checked/anketa/85475 Оценки НАТАЛЬЯ, Москва, (910)4871529
http://jockinsrinti.tk/comments/anketa/79760 Отзывы о девушке Мария, Москва, (903)7762792
http://burrighchipve.tk/ind/anketa39839.htm#tp33691 Проститутки M. Таганская - Индивидуалка ЯНА, не доступен
http://congbachessne.tk/checked/anketa/67341 Оценки Марина, Москва, (968)8467992
http://inetarem.tk/ind/anketa53196.htm Проститутки M. Багратионовская - Индивидуалка Лера, Район ЗАО, Филевский Парк, +7 (903) 783-69-99

Anonymous said...

http://burrighchipve.tk/ind/anketa50139.htm Проститутки M. Динамо - Индивидуалка Аля , +7 (916) 054-12-05
http://fracenberri1975.tk/ind/anketa74343.htm Проститутки M. Беляево - Индивидуалка Валерия, +7 (906) 746-07-45
http://deiwaltare.tk/checked/anketa/48079 Оценки Соня, Москва, (929)9762220
http://clemokfevi.tk/mass/anketa57683.htm Массажистка Таня, M. Сухаревская - +7 (919) 728-01-85
http://jockinsrinti.tk/ind/anketa76637.htm Проститутки M. Ясенево - Индивидуалка Таня, +7 (925) 708-01-79

элитные проститутки г сургут

Anonymous said...

I like [url=http://www.nikeshop.ca/]Nike[/url] and http://www.nikeshop.ca/3nwqalmt

Anonymous said...

It is Miuccia [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]Шубы оптом [/url] and Patrizio Bertelli who find the secret of Prada and invent the very first black nylon Prada handbag on the planet which opens the successful and beneficial door of world famous handbag brand. Prada Handbags is famous for its glamorous. Each lady wants a Prada handbag which shows the style and the way of life. Prada store sells cheap Prada, including Prada purses and Prada handbags. [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]шуба [/url] is the perfect method to select a bag of high quality and greatest designed. With the development of Prada, an increasing number of [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]фабрика меха [/url] are established. Getting Prada handbags and Prada wallets in [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]шуба [/url] can save you a large number of cash and time. [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]мех [/url] is yet another good choice for you. [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]мех [/url] can never disappoint you.

Tangkas Online said...

Judi Online | Agen Bola Terpercaya | We are the World's Largest Online Football Agent and Trusted. The transaction process is safe, fast and comfortable is our commitment to make our loyal customers even more pleased to recommend our services to their fellow colleagues.